Basics of Control System-2 Study notes For EE/EC

By Ankita Srivastava|Updated : July 19th, 2023

Electrical-Mechanical Analogous System is a concept that relates electrical systems to mechanical systems, drawing analogies between their components and behaviors. This approach helps engineers and scientists to analyze and design complex systems in different domains by leveraging their familiarity with one domain to understand the other. Let's explore the Translational and Rotational analogies, F-V (Force-Velocity) and F-I (Force-Current) analogies, and the conversions between electrical and mechanical domains.

In this article, you will find the study notes on Basics of a Control system which will cover the topics such as Electrical-Mechanical Analogous System: Translational & Rotational, F-V & F-I analogy, Electrical to Mechanical Conversion & Mechanical to Electrical Conversion. These topics are highly crucial for exams like GATE, ISRO, ESE, and other engineering related exams.

Download GATE Electrical Engineering Revision Sheet and Formulae PDF

Restrictions on Systems Studied

Systems considered in this article generally under the category of linear systems.A lengthier description is "Linear, Time-Invariant, Continuous-Time, Dynamic Systems." We will discuss these definitions one by one.

  • Linear System: Essentially a Linear system is one which follows the principle of Superposition & Homogeneity in their response of the system.

Consider a system with input f(t) and output x(t)

byjusexamprep

Now if the input is changed to g(t) the output is y(t)

byjusexamprep

If the system is linear, then an input of h(t)=g(t)+f(t) yields an output z(t)=x(t)+y(t)

byjusexamprep

  • Example of a nonlinear system: Now consider the same situation when the system is nonlinear for example a squaring function.

byjusexamprep

Now we can no longer find the output to the complex function, h(t), by adding the responses of the system to the simpler function.

byjusexamprep

  • Time-Invariant: In time invariant system, the physical parameters of the system do not change with time. The classic example of a non-time invariant system is a rocket whose mass changes with time (a time-invariant rocket would have constant mass).
  • Continuous-Time: The Continuous time systems are time is a continuous, or real-valued, variable. On the other hand, discrete-time systems have time that moves in discrete steps.

Examples of discrete time systems include weekly closing stock prices (updated weekly), the sound on a standard audio CD (updated 44,100 times per second).

Analogous System

An analogous electrical and mechanical system will have differential equations of the same form. There are two analogues that are used to go between electrical and mechanical system.

byjusexamprep

To understand the analogy more clearly.The entries for the mechanical analogues are formed by substituting the analogous quantities into the equations for the electrical elements.For example, the electrical version of Ohm's law is e=iR.The Mechanical I analog stipulates that e is replaced by v, I by f and R by 1/B, which yields v=f/B.

Download Formulas for GATE Electrical Engineering - Signals and Systems PDF

byjusexamprep

Force-Current 'F-I' Analogy (Electrical to Mechanical)

The important relationship when converting from a circuit to the Mechanical 1 analog is that between Kirchoff's Current Law and D'Alemberts Law (with inertial forces included).

byjusexamprep

Procedure for Conversion from Electrical to Mechanical.

  • Start with an electrical circuit.Label all node voltages.
  • Write a node equations for each node voltage.
  • Rewrite the equations using analogs making substitutions from the table, with each electrical node being replaced by a position.
  • Draw the mechanical system that corresponds with the equations.

Example: Draw the mechanical equivalent circuit of the given system.

byjusexamprep

Solution: By following the steps in given Procedure

byjusexamprep

Alternative method: Another way from electrical to mechanical simply redrawing the electrical circuit using mechanical components.

  • Draw over the circuit, replacing electrical elements with their analogs; current sources replaced by force generators, voltage sources by input velocities, resistors with friction elements, inductors with springs, and capacitors (which must be grounded) by masses. Each node becomes a position (or velocity)
  • Label currents, positions, and mechanical elements as they were in the original electrical circuits.

byjusexamprepForce-Current 'F-I'to Electrical to Mechanical

The procedure to go from Mechanical to Electrical is simply the reverse of Electrical to Mechanical. Either a mathematical method can be used as in the previous example, Electrical to Mechanical conversion can be understand by reading the table from bottom to top, or a simple visual method can be used where force generators are replaced by current sources, friction elements by resistors, springs by inductors, and masses by capacitors (which are grounded). Each position becomes a node in the circuit.

Procedure for 'F-I' analogy for Electrical to Mechanical Conversion

  • Start with the mechanical system.Label all positions.
  • Draw the circuit by replacing mechanical elements with their analogs; force generators by current sources, input velocities by voltage sources, friction elements by resistors, springs by inductors, and masses by capacitors (which are grounded).Each position becomes a node.
  • Label nodes and electrical elements as they were in the original mechanical system.

byjusexamprepForce-Voltage 'F-V' Analogy (From Electrical to Mechanical)

The important relationship when converting from a circuit to the Mechanical analog is that between Kirchoff's Voltage Law and D'Alemberts Law (with inertial forces included).

byjusexamprep

Procedure for Conversion from Electrical to Mechanical

  • Start with an electrical circuit. Label all currents. Choose currents so that only one current flows through inductors.
  • Write a loop equations for each loop.
  • Rewrite the equations using analogs, making substitutions from the table, with each electrical loop being replaced by a position.
  • Draw the mechanical system that corresponds with the equations.

Example: Draw the Mechanical equivalent system of the Electrical Circuit.

byjusexamprep

Solution: By following the procedure given for force voltage analogy.

byjusexamprep

Rotating Mechanical Systems

Gear System

Gears perform many functions, here we look at gears that increase or reduce angular velocity (while simultaneously decreasing or increasing torque, such that energy is conserved).

  • If we consider two gears in equilibrium and in contact with each other, we can two very useful relationships.byjusexamprep

  • First, we note the geometric relationship that results from the path that the arc lengths along their circumference must be equal as the gears turn.

byjusexamprep

Since the arc lengths (shown with a heavy blue line) must be equal ⇒ arc length⇒ r1θ1 = r2θ2 arc length

  • Now we can derive the second relationship from a torque balance.Here we must define a force between the gears termed a "contact force."This force must be equal and opposite across the interface between the two gears, but its direction is arbitrary.

byjusexamprep

Since the contact force is tangent to both gears and so produces a torque that is equal to the radius times the force.

byjusexamprep

We can do a torque balance on each of the two gears

For Gear 1: torque τ1 = fcr1 or fc = τ1/r1 & For Gear 2: torque τ2 = fcr2 or fc = τ2/r2

From the above two equation we concluded that fc = τ1/r1 = τ2/r2

  • In the system below, a torque, τa, is applied to gear 1 (with a moment of inertia J1). It, in turn, is connected to gear 2 (with a moment of inertia J2) and a rotational friction Br. The angle θ1 is defined positive clockwise, θ2 is defined positive clockwise. The torque acts in the direction of θ1.

byjusexamprep

  • We start by drawing free body diagrams, including a contact force that we will arbitrarily choose to be down on J1 and up on J2. The directions of the reaction forces due to inertia and friction are chosen, as always, opposite to the defined positive direction.

byjusexamprep

This yields the two equations of motion

τa + fcr1 - J1θ1 =0

fcr2-J2θ2 +Brθ2 = 0

  • We can easily solve for fc and eliminate it from the equations, but we also need to eliminate θ2. To do this we use the relationship between θ1 and θ2 (from equal arc lengths).

r1θ1 = -r2θ2

  • Note that we have a negative sign here because of the way θ1 and θ2 were defined (if θ1 moves in the positive direction, then θ2 is negative). When you use the arc length expression you must be careful of signs.

fcr2-J2θ2 - Brθ2 = 0

and θ2 = - r1/r21)

we can we write it as fcr2-J2{r1/r21)} =0

fc = -J2{r1/(r2)21 - Br {r1/(r2)21

We can put this into the equation for J1 and solve (in standard form with the output (θ1) on the left, and the input (τa) on the right.

τa + fcr1 - J1θ1 =0

or τa +[-J2{r1/(r2)2}θ1 - Br {r1/(r2)2}θ1r1] - J1θ1 =0

or {J1+ J2(r1/r2)21 + Br(r1/r2)2}θ1 = τa

So we get θ1 = r2/r12) & ω1 = r2/r12)

& Since from the relation τ1= r1/r22)

we concluded that

τ1ω1 = {r1/r22)}{r2/r12)} = τ2ω2

All the Best.

Download Formulas for GATE Electrical Engineering - Electrical Machines PDF

If you are preparing for GATE and ESE, avail Online Classroom Program to get unlimited access to all the live structured courses and mock tests from the following link:

Online Classroom Program

BYJU'S Exam Prep Test Series

Comments

write a comment

FAQs

  • Electrical-Mechanical Analogous Systems provide a powerful tool for engineers and scientists to analyze and design complex systems. By drawing analogies between electrical and mechanical components, they can leverage their expertise in one domain to gain insights into the other, facilitating problem-solving and system design.

  • To convert an electrical system to a mechanical system, you can use the analogous components and relationships. For example, you can represent electrical voltage (V) as a force (F) in the mechanical domain and electrical current (I) as velocity (V). Similarly, to convert a mechanical system to an electrical one, you can apply the appropriate analogous relationships, such as representing mechanical torque (τ) as electrical force (F) and angular velocity (ω) as current (I).

  • The choice of analogy depends on the specific characteristics of the system you are working with. Consider the nature of the forces, velocities, and currents involved, as well as the interactions between electrical and mechanical components. Select the analogy that best represents the system's behavior and simplifies its analysis.

  • Electrical-Mechanical Analogous Systems find applications in various fields, including robotics, control systems, mechatronics, electric motor design, and power electronics. They allow engineers to design and optimize complex systems by understanding the relationship between electrical and mechanical components.

Follow us for latest updates